Review
Return to Breakneck Island
by Tom Ryan

Release date: October 6th, 2026
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I received a complimentary ARC copy of Return to Breakneck Island
by Tom Ryan from Net Galley and Grove Atlantic in order to read and give an honest review.
…Combining small-town warmth, action-packed treasure hunting, and dark historical secrets, this sequel strikes a wonderful balance between a cozy mystery and a thrilling adventure. It answers the lingering questions of the MacLeary disappearance while perfectly setting the stage for the next chapter in the series….
Having read the first book in this series, The Treasure Hunters Club, I was thrilled to dive into this sequel; yet another twisty mystery set in the small coastal town of Maple Bay, Nova Scotia. As a Canadian reader, I was proud to pick up a mystery rooted in local lore and set along our gorgeous eastern coast. Tom Ryan delivers once again with Return to Breakneck Island, taking us back to Maple Bay’s coastal charm and hidden darkness.
The story treats us to dual mysteries. The first occurred in 1932 and follows the MacLeary family, who tended the lighthouse on Breakneck Island until a violent storm blew through. Their disappearance launched a local legend of a family vanishing without a trace, leaving behind no bodies and whispers of a hidden fortune. In the present day, Cass, Peter, and Dandy find themselves drawn back to the island’s secrets. While each character initially follows a separate trail, from cryptic clues about a missing manuscript to unexpected family arrivals and mysterious artifacts, their individual investigations eventually collide in a deadly puzzle.
The dual-timeline structure and multiple points of view keep the narrative moving at a brisk pace. The 1932 chapters are what truly hooked me; knowing the tragedy awaiting the MacLearys lent every historical scene a heavy, atmospheric tension. Ryan brings significant emotional depth to the story, layering themes of sacrifice, forgiveness, overcoming social mores, and the lingering psychological impact of the past. The labeled chapter headers successfully anchor the plot, making it easy to juggle the various character viewpoints across both time periods.
While I missed seeing the main trio team up as closely as they did in The Treasure Hunters Club, the payoff when their storylines finally merge is well worth it, culminating in a plot twist that caught me completely off guard. The atmospheric writing shines throughout this complex, engaging wild ride of a plot. Filled with red herrings and dynamic characters, the story seamlessly blends historical secrets with present-day danger.
Combining small-town warmth, action-packed treasure hunting, and dark historical secrets, this sequel strikes a wonderful balance between a cozy mystery and a thrilling adventure. It answers the lingering questions of the MacLeary disappearance while perfectly setting the stage for the next chapter in the series.









