
Portrait of a Witch Undone
by K.S. Shay
Release date: Augut 25th, 2026
🌟🌟🌟🌟
(3.5 rounded up)
I received a complimentary ARC copy of Portrait of a Witch Undone by by K.S. Shay from NetGalley and Kensington Publishing/ Erewhon Books in order to read and give an honest review.
…an original, incredibly captivating, atmospheric read that perfectly balances historical legacy with supernatural thrills…
Witches, an art heist and magic realism, sign me up! Reading this several qualities felt familiar this book reads like a brilliant mash up of Discovery of Witches-meets Charmed-meets-The Magicians meets -meets-art-history class. The story uses the infamous 1990 Gardner Museum theft as fodder for the story to create this fabulously layered blend of magic realism and real-world historical intrigue (I did a deep dive online with regards to the heist, interesting stuff if you are interested). The concept of human-made art functioning as a magical portal between dimensions is brilliantly unique. The world-building is well done with its the vividly creative “Other Marsh” and the little maps scattered throughout the pages it helps the setting feel incredibly immersive.
Well-written, the author authentically writes twenty-three-year-old Maeve. While readers might find her a bit young, she authentically fits into that “new adult” space as she wrestles with her corrupted magic and the weight of early adulthood. Beyond Maeve, the supporting cast really launches the plot, Ash’s vanishing acts as the driving force, while Imani’s divided loyalties create excellent friction. Though, admittedly, there were a few things that I struggled with, namely, vague physical character descriptions that make it hard to form a clear mental picture. I also deeply appreciated that the romance remained a subtle undercurrent rather than hijacking the narrative, allowing the atmospheric, slightly creepy fantasy elements to take center stage. Make no mistake, this is a heavily action-driven plot that brings fantastic momentum, but it does sometimes rely on easy coincidences to get the characters out of a jam.
Despite its imperfections, it is an original, incredibly captivating, atmospheric read that perfectly balances historical legacy with supernatural thrills. I highly recommend.









